Tuesday, April 28, 2009

Deviation Posting – Recession and 1945

Apologies for quick deviation into British history and politics today but I got a bit narked listening to the radio. The newspapers, radio and TV have quickly latched on to this idea that the recession is now the worst since World War Two in Britain. Maybe, maybe not. Politicians in the UK have decided that this means they can say that the economy (and by extension they claim life in general) is as bad as it was in 1945. This is of course nonsense and one of those arguments only possible in a world where people don’t read enough history.

Indeed to argue that anything now is like 1945 is so daft that any politician you hear mentioning this comparison should immediately have ensured you’ll never vote for them again. Just consider the picture of the Gorbals in Glasgow (which appears in David Kynaston’s excellent book noted below) above – now while the Gorbals is still far from paradise, whatever it is it isn’t anything like this anymore, the people who live there are different, the jobs they do (or don’t do) completely changed etc. In 1945 Britain was victorious but bombed out and knackered, rationing was in place, shortage widespread, the Treasury bust in a way it isn't now – to compare 2009 to 1945 is bizarre – sound bite politics I guess. Below I’ve noted a couple of books that describe that time excellently from David Kynaston and Maureen Waller that are well worth a read.

However, one thing about 1945 is instructive and we could learn from it. Right now it seems that we’re just going to let the same politicians and bankers that broke their own system put it back together way they like and that suits them best. This would be a tragedy. In 1945 Britain rejected the Tories as a party of the past (they were then, they are now) and elected a government that launched a programme of broadly socialist egalitarian ideas – the NHS, extensive nationalisation, education and housing. Politicians can try and score points by evoking images of 1945 and ruin; they might want to remember what arose from those ruins based on the idea of taking control of an economic system for the good of the many rather than just a financial elite. And, oh yeah, while I'm on a rant, bring back imperial measurements.

Austerity Britain, 1945-1951 - David Kynaston


London 1945 – Maureen Waller

6 comments:

Buy Runescape Gold said...

This individual recommended Ricky asks how to control Reuben, when it can do to help at all. Unfortunately, the George models the time to get a new love for Anne, even once a lover of the management of sick leave Mimsy Again, Ashley George and invest in opportunities for female emotions Ricky lunch. At the same time, Ben has asked Grace, in addition to meeting the needs of Ricky Ruben when his new mother can not rely on your ex anyway.
WOW Gold
RS Gold
Tera Gold
Cheap RS Gold
Tera Online Gold
Buy Tera Gold
Eden Gold
Tera Gold Cheap
Buy Runescape Gold

Buy Cheap RS Gold said...

I'm therefore glad this specific net factor works along with your report actually helped me. Normally takes you up on that property suggestions anyone

http://www.maplestorybots.com/
http://rsgame2u.com/
http://catchwow.com/

FZF said...

I'm so pleased for having the 'next' button on my page. Buy Runescape Gold Buy RS Gold
http://www.fzf.com/christmas/christmas.html

FZF said...

The post is very nicely written and yes it contains many useful facts. We are pleased to find your distinguished way of writing the post. So you allow me to learn and implement. Thank you sharing with us.
http://www.4rsgold.com/christmas/active.html
http://www.fzf.com/christmas/christmas.html

http://www.facebook.com/pages/FZF/296158577089118?ref=tn_tnmn
http://twitter.com/#!/RSGoldfzf

sanatesi520 said...

If you have enough black bags, maybe you want something different. You can find that here also. They have bags in every style and color to fit every taste and lifestyle. The hardest thing you will have to do is to choose only one, so do not just stop at one. Snakeskin embossing is used on a variety of these backpacks and bags.gucci eyeglasses for men
gucci eyeglasses for women
gucci eyeglasses frames
gucci sunglasses men
cheap gucci sunglasses

Anonymous said...

Politicians within the united kingdom have made Cheap RS Goldthe decision that this signifies they could say that this financial environment (and by extension they point out life style in general) is as bad since it absolutely was in 1945. that is effortlessly nonsense and one special of
WOW Goldindividuals arguments only feasible within a planet where by individuals do not study sufficient history.