Saturday, May 9, 2009

The Gurkhas, Justice and a National Embarrassment



It’s hard to be anything but disgusted with the British government’s attitude to the Gurkha’s and the pension row. The history of the Gurkas as fighting men in the pay of Britain goes back a long - Gurkhas served as troops under contract to the East India Company. During the Indian Rebellion of 1857, Gurkhas fought on the British side, and became part of the British Indian Army on its formation. The 2nd Gurkha Rifles (The Sirmoor Rifles) made a particularly notable contribution during the conflict, and indeed twenty-five Indian Order of Merit awards were made to men from that regiment during the Siege of Delhi. Their exploits and courage are of course legendary - the Gurkha momument in London pictured left.


From the end of the Indian Rebellion of 1857 until the start of the First World War the Gurkha Regiments saw active service in Burma, Afghanistan, the North-East and the North-West Frontiers of India, Malta (the Russo-Turkish War, 1877–78), Cyprus and Malaya. Naturally, as I hope most people know, the Gurkha’s were of course on the front line in WW1 (200,000 served with 20,000 casualties), WW2 and the Falklands among other recent conflicts. A Gurkha light infantry group pictured left about 1890.




For the purposes of this blog it’s worth remembering that the Gurka’s also saw active service in China during the Boxer Rebellion in 1900 (Gurkhas in China are pictured left) and Tibet during Younghusband's bloody Expedition of 1905. I’m not going to argue whether or not any of the wars above were politically acceptable – the Gurkha’s were a key part of the military arm of the British Empire obviously. Still, the current (and long running – all my life as far as I can remember) row about why Gurkhas receive smaller pensions than their British equivalents sticks in the throat as fundamentally unfair, racist and a prime example of petty government penny saving.


There is a campaign currently running to support Gurkhas and pressure the UK government into giving more help and equal treatment to Gurkhas, called Gurkha Justice that has caught the public’s imagination and widespread support. A motion was voted on in the House of Commons on the 29th April 2009 by the Liberal Democrats that all Gurkhas be offered an equal right of residence in the UK. This resulted in a defeat for the Government by 267 votes to 246, the first, first day motion defeat for a government since 1978. The Commons vote is not binding, but it represents an embarrassment for the government. Yet Phil Woolas, the immigration minister (and, as I well remember a nasty little self-centred careerist when he was head of the National Union Students in my college days - a real horrible little greasy pole climber who obviously hasn't changed one jot) continues to prevaricate and pettifog.


If you want to support the campaign for full Gurkha Justice – on their site you can sign the petition calling calling on the UK Government to act immediately to change the law to allow all retired Gurkhas the right to stay in the UK, without reservation. (By the way if you sign the online petition you subsequently get a thank you email from none other than Joanna Lumley, which for all Englishmen of a certain age is rather thrilling!)

8 comments:

Jin Yang said...

sorry but thats not gurkha pic. http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_g2ofm4KCX5k/SgVKDJAo70I/AAAAAAAABUM/i0oXI2C6dQ4/s1600-h/gurkha+in+Boxer.jpg

they looks more like rajputs..

cheerz fo articles.

Paul French said...

that's what I thought too - but they're on the British army's Gurkha regiment web site so they should know I guess!

Anonymous said...

I believe after reading your article, with fewer I's in it than any Obama speech. My first thought is someone does not play well with others. And my second thought is the same.

Biber said...

I came across a nice quote while re-reading Randall Gould's great China memoir China in the Sun the other day. Gould was a veteran member of the old China press corps before the war.

cheapest wow gold|Tera account|Tera gold|buy eden gold|wow gold

Cheap RS Gold said...

This can be a great inspiring article. We are basically satisfied with your good work. You'd put really very useful information.
http://goldgame.org/

Anonymous said...

Learning the alphabet item directory Guild wars 2 gold site

Best and greatest method of getting rich and maintain make an buy Guild wars 2 gold impression on golden is to get started on with a decent, Hot direct booklet of all the variants of to multiple-Level of skill areas of the game of craps. The following are some good hints that could be found in this particular guide confirm.

Anonymous said...

From the accomplish while using Indian Rebellion of 1857 right up until the Buy Runescape Goldcommence while using original world battle the Gurkha Regiments observed energetic help in Burma, Afghanistan, the North-East too for the reliable reason that North-West Frontiers of India, the island of malta Buy Cheapest WOW Gold(the Russo-Turkish War, 1877–78),

singhets said...


“ETS (etradeservices)Packers and Movers Bangalore has been a top-rated moving company that not only offers high-quality services to satisfy customer's”
movers and packers in bangalore
movers and packers in hyderabad
packers and movers bangalore